Fracking ban upheld by France's constitutional council
France looks unlikely to capitalise on its shale gas resources after a ruling by its constitutional council
France's constitutional council has rejected a challenge to a law banning fracking for shale gas and oil.
Today’s ruling is a boost for President Francois Hollande, who has opposed fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, technology alongside Greens in his ruling coalition – to the dismay of some allies who believe France is sacrificing access to a cheap source of energy.
US-based firm Schuepbach Energy had challenged on four counts a ban introduced in 2011 due to potential risks to the environment, which led to two of its exploration permits being cancelled in southern France.
"The constitutional council threw out these four complaints and ruled that the disputed components of the July 13, 2011 law comply with the constitution," the court said in a statement.
The Constitutional Council, made up of judges and former French presidents, has the power to annul laws if they are deemed to be unconstitutional.
France's Energy Minister Philippe Martin said the ruling meant the law banning fracking, in which pressurised water, chemicals and sand are pumped underground to release gas trapped in shale formations, was now safe from other legal challenges.
"It's a legal victory, but also an environmental and political one," Martin said at a news briefing.
The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) estimates shale gas reserves of about five trillion cubic meters could lie in French soil, mainly in the Paris basin and the Rhone valley – equivalent to 90 years of current French gas consumption.
However, it had not been possible to confirm those estimates because of the ban on fracking. Other countries such as Poland saw its hopes for shale gas fade after three international firms quit after disappointing drilling results.
So-called fracking was banned in France under former President Nicolas Sarkozy on concerns it could pollute groundwater and trigger earthquakes, bringing to a halt the nascent shale oil and gas industry in France.
Jean-Louis Schilansky, head of France's oil industry lobby UFIP, said it was key for the government to fully implement the law, which includes an article asking for a commission to assess the progress of fracking technologies.
After France put the ban in place, Schuepbach Energy said it had no alternative way to carry out the exploration, which led to the suspension of its two permits in the south of France.
French oil major Total is still awaiting a ruling after it separately appealed at the end of 2011 the government's decision to ban its own exploration permit by the south-eastern town of Montelimar.
Industry Minister Arnaud Montebourg stirred debate earlier this year when he suggested creating a state-backed company to examine alternative exploration techniques.
"There has been a lot of talk about the reported £30bn cost of the Sochi Games, so we go behind the scenes to find out where all that money has been spent"
- Repeated Alternator Failure on Power Plant rated 16MVA/ 11,000V using 12x 415V generators [06:53 pm 10/03/14]
- How and when will DECC's electricity capacity market fail? [01:30 pm 10/03/14]
- Technology that has died since the year 2000 [12:14 pm 10/03/14]
- what about intematix led assembly ? [11:33 am 10/03/14]
- High Voltage Breakdown 315KeV [06:24 pm 09/03/14]
The essential source of engineering products and suppliers.
Tune into our latest podcast