Call to capitalise on smart meter roll-out delay

15 May 2013
By Edd Gent
Mobile version
Share |
Dr Martyn Thomas told the Government to use the time afforded by the smart meter roll out delay to formalise specifications for the system

Dr Martyn Thomas told the Government to use the time afforded by the smart meter roll out delay to formalise specifications for the system

The IET has called for the government to capitalise on the smart meter roll-out delay to formalise specifications for the system.

Dr Martyn Thomas, chairman of the IET’s IT policy panel, gave evidence yesterday to the Energy and Climate Change Committee on the government’s smart meter roll-out program after the project was delayed last week.

The Department for Energy and Climate Change (DECC) announced last Friday that the introduction of energy smart meters in 30 million UK homes will be delayed for more than a year, with the first stage of the roll-out not starting until autumn 2015.

DECC claimed the decision was due to bidders for the data and communication infrastructure required to support the roll-out asking for more time to design and test their systems.

While many commentators have criticised the delay Thomas said the government should take advantage of the time to formalise specifications for the system which are currently expressed informally, leading to the danger of “inconsistency, ambiguity and contradiction”.

“We would press very strongly that the time we now have before the mass roll-out should be used, in part, to formalise and properly analyse the specifications for the meters, for the overall architecture and for the security properties and to prove those things are consistent.

“We know how to do that, it’s not expensive and there’s time in the program to do that.”

Thomas pointed out that the smart meter program would serve as the basis for the ultimate goal of a smart grid and that it was important not to make mistakes in the early stages of the project.

“The roll-out timescales really do need to be based on the engineering realities rather than determined by judgements made by politicians or by senior civil servants for political reasons,” he said.

“If we don’t do that we will inevitably make mistakes and get it wrong and we will get cost and time overruns. We will make mistakes that have to be fixed later.”

The costs of the roll-out, now due to be completed by 2020, will be passed on to consumers in their bills but DECC estimates that smart metering will bring a net benefit of £6.7bn.

But GMB, the union for workers in the energy sector, says the lack of clarity from government has allowed some energy companies to do little on smart meters in the hope they can “scupper the whole agenda”.

Gary Smith, GMB national secretary for Energy, said: “The slippage in the time line for the full scale roll out of smart meters is bad for jobs and customers. It is a signal that DECC is in a mess and the government is struggling over energy policy.

“Smart meters are good for customers. Research tells us customers save 5 per cent on energy bills. Experience in America shows it is more. Smart meters are key in the government’s agenda to make it easier for customers to switch suppliers.

“The lack of progress on smart meters has undermined confidence for those investing in the industry. More jobs could and should have been created by now. The lack of clarity from government has allowed some energy companies to do little on smart meters in the hope they can scupper the whole agenda.

“All energy companies must be compelled to hit clear targets on smart meters by a specified time frame. If we don't have these clear commitments the timetable will slip further.”

But the British Electrotechnical and Allied Manufacturers Association (BEAMA), which represents manufacturers involved in the roll-out, said it welcomed the announcement.

“The postponement of the mass roll-out to 2015 will allow sufficient time for all the industry players to develop and test the systems required to make the roll-out a complete success,” it said in a statement.

Stuart Ravens, principal energy and sustainability technology analyst at Ovum, said giving retailers like British Gas and EDF responsibility for the smart meter roll-out had created some unique issues.

"Ovum has for some time been critical of the selection process for smart meters,” he said. “In all other deployments worldwide, metering is the responsibility of network operators, not retailers. So each network operator is responsible for discrete geographic areas and able to select the right communications technology for its area. In practice, this is usually a hybrid of different communications.

“In the British deployment, retailers have no geographic constraints, nor have they historically shown much interest in trialling and testing a variety of communications technologies. With very few exceptions, the smart meters deployed in Britain so far have relied on cellular-based communications, with mixed results.

"DECC decided, in its wisdom, to divide Britain into three regions and invited tenders for each of these regions. Part of the DECC's tendering process was to request proof that each communications technology would work in the British deployment.

“However, it did not commission any trials itself. If the tendering process were to proceed as previously planned, Britain could have commissioned a communications network for over 50 million meters that had not been properly tested.

"The DECC's decision to delay the tendering process by at least a year to perform more tests is welcome, but it does beg the question: why did it take the DECC so long to recognise its previous folly?"

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1604

"Should the UK's engineers be in or out of Europe? The IET sets out its official position on the EU referendum this week - will you agree?"

->

E&T jobs

  • Senior Programme Manager

    Network Rail
    • England, London
    • £76800 - £86400 per annum

    Do you possess a track record of taking the lead on large projects?

    • Recruiter: Network Rail

    Apply for this job

  • Professor and Head of the Department of Electrical and Computer Systems Engineering

    Monash University
    • Australia (AU)

    Shape the future direction of a Department which is currently involved in ground breaking innovative research

    • Recruiter: Monash University

    Apply for this job

  • Rail Engineer

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Burton, Dorking, Glasgow
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    Some of the most exciting infrastructure projects in the UK over the coming years are in rail.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Power & HV Engineers

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Glasgow, Gloucester, Plymouth, Warrington
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    Frazer-Nash is currently embarking on a period of significant growth of our electrical, electronics, control and instrumentation capability.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Control and Instrumentation Engineers

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Dorchester, Glasgow, Gloucester, Plymouth, Warrington
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    Frazer-Nash is currently embarking on a period of significant growth of our electrical, electronics, control and instrumentation capability.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Open Days

    Atkins
    • Bristol, Epsom and Birmingham

    Meet your new team!

    • Recruiter: Atkins

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Manager

    Crich Tramway Village
    • Crich, Derbyshire
    • £40,000 PA

    The post holder will be a qualified electrical engineer and have experience in running a workshop and extensive project management skills.

    • Recruiter: Crich Tramway Village

    Apply for this job

  • CONNECTIONS DESIGNER

    SSE
    • MELKSHAM, NEW FOREST, OXFORD, POOLE, PORTSMOUTH, READING AND SLOUGH
    • £33,520 TO £49,645 (SSE7/8) DEPENDING ON SKILLS AND EXPERIENCE

    Due to continued growth, we are looking to recruit a number of Connections Designers in to existing network offices in South Central England.

    • Recruiter: SSE

    Apply for this job

  • Junior PLC Software Engineer

    Siemens
    • Gatwick

    Designs and develops controls SW, prepares engineering calculations, performs analyses and supports factory acceptance tests

    • Recruiter: Siemens

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Engineer

    Premium job

    Scottish Prison Service
    • Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh
    • £40,654 to £48,579 plus annual supplement of £10,000

    Build Your Engineering Career. The Scottish Prison Service (SPS) is an Agency of the Scottish Government, working in partnership.....

    • Recruiter: Scottish Prison Service

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶

Subscribe

Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T