Setback for high-speed rail plan

15 March 2013
By Sofia Mitra-Thakur
Mobile version
Share |
Government consultations on compensating those affected by the proposed HS2 high-speed rail scheme have been ruled

Government consultations on compensating those affected by the proposed HS2 high-speed rail scheme have been ruled

The government's HS2 high-speed rail scheme suffered a setback when the High Court ruled that the consultation process for compensating those affected by the multibillion-pound project "was so unfair as to be unlawful".

The decision was a victory for the High Speed 2 Action Alliance (HS2AA), consisting of more than 70 affiliated action groups and residents' associations.

The HS2AA case on consultation was one of five separate cases brought to block the controversial scheme in its current form. It was the only case to succeed.

Mr Justice Ouseley, sitting at London's High Court, is now hearing submissions from lawyers on the appropriate remedy.

The first phase of HS2 would see a high-speed line running through Tory heartlands from London to Birmingham.

A second phase extends the line to Leeds and Manchester to create what will become known as "the Y network".

The project is designed to cut journey times, ease overcrowding and boost regional business.

The government hailed the court's decision on the cases it won as a "landmark victory" and said the loss on the compensation case would "not affect the HS2 construction timetable in any way".

Rail Minister Simon Burns said: "This is a major landmark victory for HS2 and the future of Britain.

The judge has categorically given the green light for the government to press ahead without delay in building a high-speed railway from London to Birmingham, Manchester and Leeds."

The then transport secretary Justine Greening gave HS2 the go-ahead in January 2012.

The judge said the £33 million scheme might in future be extended to Glasgow and Edinburgh, while the first phase would include a direct link with the existing high-speed Channel Tunnel rail link (HS1).

The judge stressed that it was not his task to review the merits of HS2 itself, but to consider whether the decisions setting it up were legally flawed.

He identified 10 grounds raised in the five cases brought by various opponents, including 18 local councils, scores of residents' associations and action groups, plus farmers and a golf club.

He rejected nine out of 10 of the grounds, which included attacks on the manner in which the project had been steered through Parliament and alleged breaches of EU environmental and habitat directives.

He also dismissed allegations that the government failed to take account of relevant issues and was guilty of indirect discrimination because of the impact of redevelopment of London's Euston station on the local ethnic minority community.

The 10th - and only successful - challenge was HS2AA's claim that the consultation and decision-making process on compensation was "fundamentally unfair".

Some 172,000 properties within 0.6 miles (1km) of the first phase are alleged to be affected by "HS2 blight".

David Wolfe QC, appearing for HS2AA, said tens of thousands of people who "just happen to live and own properties" along the high-speed route faced loss of value on their homes and being unable to move or remortgage for 15 years or more.

Mr Wolfe told the judge that 172,000 affected households had been contacted. 

Householders faced inadequate compensation and the prospect of unfairly being made to suffer because of the claimed public interest in HS2 going ahead.

He said the consultation process was flawed because of "lack of detail" and insufficient information from Ms Greening on the options for a discretionary compensation scheme.

Allowing the HS2AA challenge, Mr Justice Ouseley ruled: "Although the overall decision is not irrational, the carefully reasoned and substantial HS2AA consultation response addressing the consultation issues as framed by the Secretary of State cannot have been conscientiously considered.

"All in all, the consultation on compensation was so unfair as to be unlawful."

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1606

"Where would Frankenstein and his creative mind fit into today's workplace? Should we fear technological developments or embrace them?"

E&T jobs

  • Maritime Engineering Opportunities

    Defence Equipment & Support (DE&S)
    • Bristol
    • £30,424 - £35,285

    You will be working alongside a team of people who are immensely proud of what they do in providing the best possible service to our Armed Forces

    • Recruiter: Defence Equipment & Support (DE&S)

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Manager

    BAE Systems
    • Hampshire, England, Portsmouth
    • Competitive package

    Would you like to play a vital role in managing and implementing the correct governance in order to enable BAE Systems to provide assurance and integrity of supply chain data? We currently have a vacancy for an Engineering Manager - Product Integrity

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Consultant Engineer - Test

    BAE Systems
    • Farnborough, Hampshire, England
    • Negotiable

    Consultant Engineer - Test Would you like to be a lead within an exciting team working on one of the UK's largest defence projects? We currently have a vacancy for a Consultant Engineer - Test at our site in Ash Vale. As a Consultant Engineer - Test, you

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Structural Designer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Barrow-In-Furness, Cumbria
    • Negotiable

    Structural Designer BAE Systems is looking to recruit multiple Structural Designers to join our Maritime Submarines unit to be based in our site in Barrow-in-Furness, as the Trident Replacement Programme progresses towards the start of the build stage in

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Mechanical Design Engineer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Hampshire, Portsmouth
    • Negotiable

    Mechanical Design Engineer Would you like to work in an interesting and challenging role with the chance to gain exposure to a number of maritime projects? We currently have a vacancy for a Mechanical Design Engineer at our site in Portsmouth. As a Design

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Operations Manager

    BAE Systems
    • England, Barrow-In-Furness, Cumbria
    • Negotiable

    Operations Manager We currently have an opportunity for an Operations Manager to join our Maritime - Submarines business area at our Barrow-In-Furness site. As the Operations Manager you will work within a Construction or Manufacturing Facility and be res

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Principal Chemist

    BAE Systems
    • Barrow-In-Furness, Cumbria, England
    • Negotiable

    Principal Chemist Would you like to play a key role in the safety and assurance of submarines for the Royal Navy? We currently have a vacancy for a Principal Chemist at our site in Barrow-in-Furness. As a Principal Chemist, you will be carrying out a rang

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Software Engineer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Hampshire, Portsmouth
    • Competitive package

    As a Software Engineer, you will be investigating how technology and data can be used to optimise the services we provide to our clients, including the Royal Navy, and will include unique pieces of equipment at the forefront of innovation.

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Principal Control Systems Engineer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Cumbria, Barrow-In-Furness
    • Competitive package

    As a Principal Engineer you will be responsible for the design and integration of control systems at a safety integrity level (SIL) 3. This will include requirements management, system design, and integration into the wider platform.

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Ship Refit Operations Manager

    BAE Systems
    • Jubail, Saudi Arabia
    • Negotiable

    Ship Refit Operations Manager Would you like to work with some of the largest defence projects in the world, with the chance to deploy on a contract basis to Jubail, Saudi Arabia with increased allowances? An exciting opportunity has arisen to join BAE Sy

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶

Subscribe

Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T