Japanese airlines ground Boeing Dreamliners

16 January 2013
By Sofia Mitra-Thakur
Mobile version
Share |
Passengers walk away from ANA's Boeing 787 Dreamliner which made an emergency landing at Takamatsu airport, western Japan

Passengers walk away from ANA's Boeing 787 Dreamliner which made an emergency landing at Takamatsu airport, western Japan

Japan's two leading airlines grounded their fleets of Boeing 787s this week after one of the Dreamliner passenger jets made an emergency landing, the latest in a series of incidents to heighten safety concerns over a plane many see as the future of commercial aviation.

All Nippon Airways said instruments aboard a domestic flight indicated a battery error, triggering emergency warnings to the pilots.

Shigeru Takano, a senior safety official at the Civil Aviation Bureau, said a second warning light indicated smoke.

The incident on Wednesday, described by a transport ministry official as "highly serious" – language used in international safety circles as indicating there could have been an accident – is the latest in a line of mishaps – fuel leaks, a battery fire, wiring problem, brake computer glitch and cracked cockpit window – to hit the world's first mainly carbon-composite airliner in recent days.

"I think you're nearing the tipping point where they need to regard this as a serious crisis," said Richard Aboulafia, a senior analyst with the Teal Group in Fairfax, Virginia. "This is going to change people's perception of the aircraft if they don't act quickly."

ANA, which said the battery in the forward cargo hold was the same lithium-ion type as one involved in a fire on another Dreamliner at a US airport last week, grounded all 17 of its 787s, and Japan Airlines suspended its 787 flights scheduled for Wednesday and Thursday.

ANA and JAL said they would decide on Thursday whether to resume Dreamliner flights the following day.

ANA and JAL operate around half of the 50 Dreamliners delivered by Boeing to date. The 787, which has a list price of $207m, represents a leap in the way planes are designed and built, but the project has been plagued by cost overruns and years of delays.

Some have suggested Boeing's rush to get planes built after those delays resulted in the recent problems, a charge the company strenuously denies.

Both the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) said they were monitoring the latest incident as part of a comprehensive review of the Dreamliner announced late last week.

ANA flight 692 left Yamaguchi in western Japan shortly after 8am local time (2300 GMT Tuesday) bound for Haneda Airport near Tokyo, a 65-minute flight.

About 18 minutes into the flight, at 30,000ft, the plane began a descent, cutting its altitude to 20,000ft in about four minutes. It made an emergency landing 16 minutes later, according to flight-tracking website Flightaware.com.

A spokesman for Osaka airport authority said the plane landed at Takamatsu at 8:45am.

All 129 passengers and eight crew evacuated via the plane's inflatable chutes. Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga said five people were slightly injured.

At a news conference – where ANA's vice-president Osamu Shinobe bowed deeply in apology – the carrier said a battery in the forward cargo hold triggered emergency warnings to the pilots, who decided on the emergency action.

"There was a battery alert in the cockpit and there was an odd smell detected in the cockpit and cabin, and [the pilot] decided to make an emergency landing," Shinobe said.

Passengers leaving the ANA flight told local TV there was an odour like burning plastic on the plane as soon as it took off.

"There was a bad smell as soon as we started and before we made the emergency landing there was an announcement and the stewardess' voice was shaking, so I thought this was serious," one passenger told TBS TV.

Another man told a local broadcaster: "There was a strong, burning smell, but the smoke appeared after they opened the emergency doors, after we landed."

Marc Birtel, a Boeing spokesman, said: "We've seen the reports, we're aware of the events and are working with our customer."

Robert Stallard, analyst at RBC Capital Markets, said lost revenue at the Japanese airlines could prompt compensation from Boeing.

"What started as a series of relatively minor, isolated incidents now threatens to overhang Boeing until it can return confidence, and this looks to be a near-term challenge given the media's draw to all things 787," he said.

In Asia, only the Japanese and Air India have the Dreamliner in service, but other airlines globally have ordered around 850 of the new aircraft.

Australia's Qantas Airways said its order for 15 Dreamliners remained on track, with its Jetstar subsidiary due to take delivery of the first of the aircraft in the second half of this year.

India's regulator said it would wait for a safety report from Boeing, expected later today, before deciding whether to ground the six Dreamliners operated by state-owned Air India.

"We have formed a small team and are having discussions with Boeing as well as Air India, and working out the basic problems to the basic electrical systems, and then we'll take a final call on this," Arun Mishra, Director General of Civil Aviation told reporters.

United Airlines, the only US carrier now flying the 787, said it was not taking any immediate action in response to the latest incident.

"We are looking at what is happening with ANA and we will have more information tomorrow," a spokeswoman said.

The Dreamliner's problems echo those of rival Airbus, which a year ago survived a crisis of public confidence after a series of incidents with wing cracks on its A380, the world's largest passenger jet. 

Those problems tested the manufacturer's relations with airlines, but no plane orders were cancelled.

Shares in GS Yuasa, a Japanese firm that makes batteries for the Dreamliner, fell 4.5 per cent. The Kyoto-based firm said it was too early to comment on the situation.

The use of new battery technology is among the cost-saving features of the 787, which Boeing says burns 20 per cent less fuel than rival jets using older technology.

Lithium-ion batteries can catch fire if they are overcharged, and once alight, they are difficult to put out as the chemicals produce oxygen, Boeing's chief engineer for the 787, Mike Sinnett, said last week.

He said then that lithium-ion was not the only choice of battery, but "it was the right choice".

Shares in other Dreamliner suppliers in Japan came under pressure, with Toray Industries, which supplies carbon fibre used in the plane's composites, also down 4.5 per cent, and Fuji Heavy Industries, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries and IHI off 2.5-4 per cent on a benchmark Nikkei that was 2.6 per cent lower. ANA shares slipped 1.6 per cent.

Japan's transport minister acknowledged that passenger confidence in the Dreamliner was at stake, as both Japan and the US have opened broad and open-ended investigations into the plane after the recent incidents.

The 787 is Boeing's first new jet in more than a decade, and the company's financial fortunes are largely tied to its success.

The plane offers airlines unprecedented fuel economy, but the huge investment to develop it coupled with years of delay in delivery has caused headaches for customers, hurt Boeing financially, and created a delivery bottleneck.

Boeing has said it will at least break even on the cost of building the 1,100 new 787s it expects to deliver over the next decade.

Some analysts, however, say Boeing may never make money from the plane, given its enormous development cost.

Any additional cost from fixing problems discovered by the string of recent incidents would affect those forecasts, and could hit Boeing's bottom line more quickly if it has to stop delivering planes, analysts said.

Share |

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1404

"Power cuts might seem like a 1970s fad, but they could be on the way back. How can we prevent them happening again?"

E&T videos

TomTom mapping the neighbourhood

E&T jobs

E&T Marketplace

The essential source of engineering products and suppliers.

E&T podcast

Tune into our latest podcast

iTunes logo

Subscribe

Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T