Heavy lobbying over tar sands legislation

17 April 2013
By Pelle Neroth
Mobile version
Share |
Shell excavates oil sands from mines in Alberta (credit Shell)

Shell excavates oil sands from mines in Alberta (credit Shell)

Oil from tar sands is the latest battlefield between the environmentalists and fossil fuel interests, with Canada presented as the “bad guy” (by the environmentalists) this time.

Canada has the second largest reserves of oil in the world – estimated at165 billion barrels, behind Saudi Arabia – if it can exploit this relatively novel form of resource.

Tar sands (or oil sands) are bitumen-saturated sand and clay deposits that require more energy to extract than conventional oil.

The resource, which can be exploited with modern technology, is Canada’s big new bonanza.

The European Commission cites studies showing that, according to well-to-wheel calculations, tar sands oil generates 23 per cent more greenhouse gases than ordinary crude.

The Commission therefore wants to put oil from tar sands into its own polluting category.

The Canadian federal and Albertan regional governments dread such a categorisation.

They have made common cause with oil firms active in Alberta’s tar sands fields and have sympathy from some European governments – notably in Britain and the Netherlands, with their concerns for Shell – because the European policy approach may set a precedent in other parts of the world.

It will also make it harder for oil firms to comply with the EU’s Fuel Quality Directive, which is designed to enforce the supply of considerably less polluting fossil fuels to the market.

Canadian lobbying has been intense. At times in the past three years, government ministers have been visiting Brussels to lobby MEPs almost every month, and Canadian embassy officers around Europe are well briefed on the merits of tar sands oil.

It is a big issue for Canadian interests, even if as yet European imports of tar sands oil are minuscule.

It is a public relations battle which the Canadian government fears could impact on exports to the far more important US market.

Canada knows that tar sands oil appeals to America’s need for ‘energy security’.

It is a source of transport fuel that does not derive from the Middle East and is in no danger of being “used to fund terrorist movements”.

The tar sands lobby cites consultancy studies to claim that the greenhouse gas emissions quoted by the European Commission are slightly exaggerated – that the difference is more like 10-15 per cent than 23 per cent – which puts it on a par with some normal crudes from Nigeria and Venezuela.

They say these figures will get steadily better as extraction methods improve.

They also assert that if the Europeans don’t buy Canadian oil other countries will, so global emissions will not be much reduced.

The Canadians can claim some success from their efforts.

The final decision to categorise tar sands oil separately has been put off by the EU several times, though a final decision is expected this autumn.

Several MEPs on the right and on the industry committee are said to be persuaded by the Canadian arguments.

For their part, Green lobbyists in Brussels point out that Canadian greens and indigenous groups say their voices are never heard when MEPs are taken on PR trips to tar sand areas like Fort McMurray in Alberta.

The bitter discussions taking place between the EU and Canada may be a bit technical for the general public, but they illustrate the increasing desperation to exploit the world’s dwindling fossil fuel resources.

And this situation will be with us for a time yet, as the transport sector’s need for oil will continue for the foreseeable future.

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1606

"Where would Frankenstein and his creative mind fit into today's workplace? Should we fear technological developments or embrace them?"

E&T jobs

  • Graduate Electrical Engineers

    AECOM
    • United Kingdom and Ireland
    • Competitive

    Due to the diverse nature of our business there are many different teams each with very different responsibilities.

    • Recruiter: AECOM

    Apply for this job

  • Network Innovation Engineer / Analyst - UK Power Sector

    Premium job

    Nortech Management Ltd
    • Birmingham, West Midlands or Pershore (Worcestershire)
    • £30,000 - £35,000 (depending on experience) + benefits

    Network Innovation Engineer / Analyst to join a team of talented technology enthusiasts who design and support the low carbon networks of the future.

    • Recruiter: Nortech Management Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Engineer with Strong telecoms background

    Premium job

    Sure South Atlantic Ltd
    • Falkland Islands

    Sure South Atlantic Ltd currently has a unique engineering opportunity in their Falkland Islands office. Surrounded by the Atlantic Ocean, teeming ...

    • Recruiter: Sure South Atlantic Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Cyber, Communication, Information and Data Scientist roles

    Premium job

    Dstl
    • Porton Down, Salisbury
    • Competitive salaries

    Information is everything. Use it to serve your country and help keep us safe.

    • Recruiter: Dstl

    Apply for this job

  • Production Engineer

    Premium job

    Compact Engineering
    • Thirsk / Leeds / Banbury / Colchester / Cambridge
    • Salary will be competitive and commensurate with experience, knowledge, aptitude and capability

    A Production Engineer with some knowledge and understanding of radiant energy transfer.

    • Recruiter: Compact Engineering

    Apply for this job

  • Electronics Engineer

    Premium job

    Nikon Metrology Europe
    • Tring, Hertfordshire

    Nikon Metrology is looking for an Electronics Engineer to join our Electronics Team based in Tring (UK).

    • Recruiter: Nikon Metrology Europe

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Manager

    BAE Systems
    • Hampshire, England, Portsmouth
    • Competitive package

    Would you like to play a vital role in managing and implementing the correct governance in order to enable BAE Systems to provide assurance and integrity of supply chain data? We currently have a vacancy for an Engineering Manager - Product Integrity

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Project Manager - Electrical & Automation

    Nestle
    • York, North Yorkshire
    • c£45,000 + Car Allowance + Bonus + Excellent Benefits

    Nestlé Product Technology Centre in York currently has an excellent opportunity for an Engineering Project Manager

    • Recruiter: Nestle

    Apply for this job

  • Consultant Engineer - Test

    BAE Systems
    • Farnborough, Hampshire, England
    • Negotiable

    Consultant Engineer - Test Would you like to be a lead within an exciting team working on one of the UK's largest defence projects? We currently have a vacancy for a Consultant Engineer - Test at our site in Ash Vale. As a Consultant Engineer - Test, you

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • ELECTRICAL PROJECT ENGINEER

    SSE
    • Reading, Berkshire
    • SALARY: £37,588 TO £55,669 + CAR (SSE8/9), DEPENDING ON SKILLS AND EXPERIENCE

    SSE are looking to recruit an Electrical Project Engineer into office in Reading

    • Recruiter: SSE

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶

Subscribe

Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T