vol 9, issue 7

LGBT survey: E&T hears from the engineering industry

14 July 2014
By Abi Grogan
Share |
I am open about my sexual orientation at work graph

In comparison: respondents to a survey by the Architects’ Journal 74% are comfortable about being out in the workplace

I would like to be more open about my sexual orientation at work graph

In comparison: respondents to a survey by the Architects’ Journal 13% are not comfortable about being out in the workplace

I feel my colleagues discriminate against me because of my sexual orientation graph

1 in 5 respondents to the Architects’ Journal have experienced offensive or inappropriate comments in the workplace

My sexual orientation creates barriers to my career progression graph

59% of respondents to the Architects’ Journal say their sexual orientation doesn't create barriers to their career progression

Please indicate your gender and Please indicate your sexuality or gender identity graphs

Gender, sexuality or gender identity

What country do you work in graph

‘While working with clients overseas I have felt it absolutely essential not to disclose my personal circumstances...’ Anonymous

Does your sexual orientation affect your progression in the workplace? Are your colleagues accepting of your sexuality? Is it irrelevant to your role or should you be out and proud in the office? We asked E&T’s LGBT engineering community to share their experiences of working within the industry.

“A lot of employers take the stance: ‘why should we care what you get up to in the bedroom?’. But really the question is; if you’re not comfortable at work can you perform at your best?” Chris Edwards is client group manager at LGB rights charity Stonewall, which helps companies achieve best practice in terms of sexual equality. In an attempt to address the perception that engineering is more LGBT-discriminatory than other industries, E&T recently conducted a survey into the experiences of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender engineers in the workplace.

While many will question the relevance an engineer’s sexuality bears on their employment, it may help to look at the issue in regards to profit. Studies have shown that workplaces that are truly inclusive are proven to attract and retain staff that are more creative, productive and able to reach their full potential. This is particularly pertinent in industries such as engineering, which is not only experiencing a skills shortage but is also struggling to recruit younger engineers into an ageing workforce.

EY (formerly Ernst & Young) has conducted global research showing that employees in fully inclusive environments bring in over £70,000 per year more to an organisation than those working in areas where they feel they can’t be themselves.

Honesty is the best policy

The E&T survey respondents are almost evenly split in their openness at work about their sexuality. Just over 45 per cent say they are open at work about their sexuality, while 41.8 per cent say they are not.

The 45.2 per cent who are open support EY’s study that being out at work has increased productivity. One respondent says: “I have developed the most productive professional relationships with colleagues that I have been open with about my sexual orientation.” Others say the changing marital legal landscape has allowed them to be more open, while another claims a supportive recruitment process allowed him to “come out during the hiring interview”.

Forty-six per cent of participants would like to be out more but feel their work culture would not react positively. “I think that others would lose respect for me, which in my position would affect my ability to get projects done,” says one respondent. Others feel the diversity measures currently in place would not protect them: “I do not want to be known as the ‘gay engineer’,” says one, while another warns: “It would be a disaster [coming out]. The senior management in engineering companies are – as a generalisation – homophobic. They may pay lip service to diversity policies, but that is how it is in the UK in 2014. Unfortunately.”

Some felt that taking part in conversations about their home life could be construed as “attention-seeking”. Edwards stresses the importance of a working environment where you’re able to be yourself. “This is how we build relationships both with colleagues and clients, and if gay people can’t do this they are being excluded from this relationship-building process,” he says.

“It’s much more difficult to perform as effectively as you’d want to because you’re always having to judge situations or scenarios on whether this is the right place to come out, if someone asks me what I did over the weekend, how do I answer that? I’m always having to make these judgment calls on whether this is the right environment for me to say that I was with my boyfriend.”

Respondents to our survey echo Edwards’ fears, saying: “It would be a relief to never have to pretend to be something I’m not for the first time in my life.” And: “It would be easier not to have to compartmentalise two parts of my life. Sexuality is a small part of me; at work I’d like it to be a non-issue.”

The glass ceiling

But it’s not just social functions or office chit-chat that many LGBT engineers feel excluded from. Around 17 per cent feel that their sexuality has created a barrier to their career progression. Some noted a clear decrease in casual conversations when their managers discovered their orientation, which led to less professional interaction. “I was overlooked for promotions, hence my departure to another company.”

Several engineers felt their careers had been hindered due to the public perception of the traditional engineer, saying the main barrier to promotion was that they didn’t fit the archetypal engineering manager mould: “A straight man, married to a wife who is happy to look after the children while you travel.” Another, working in the defence industry, was told during an appraisal that he needed to be “more alpha-male to succeed in the UK defence industry”. Some even feel they have lost their jobs due to discrimination at managerial level.

Emmeline Tang, lead consulting engineer of Mission Critical Services at Arup, says these experiences are not uncommon, and that many LGBT engineers experience a culture of tolerance at work rather than acceptance. “One of my directors [at a previous employer] favoured another [straight, male] engineer over me and nominated him for an award for a project that I’d been working on but he had never really been involved in,” she says. “Although it wasn’t outright homophobia, the whole office noticed this and commented on it: it was discrimination.”

Home and away

Engineering is a global industry and, as a result, engineers in certain sectors such as oil and gas are able to undertake contracts to work on projects abroad. Many engineers feel homophobic law in regions such as Africa or the Middle East prevents them from undertaking these projects and hinders their career choices. One says: “My company has a lot of overseas opportunities; some of these are in countries where I wouldn’t be comfortable being a gay person. This barrier to taking opportunities could potentially hinder my career progression.”

Other respondents speak of feeling unsafe working in certain regions: “I am discriminated against as I am limited in the involvement I can achieve due to laws that would be a threat to my liberty and life.”

Tang, who originates from Singapore where it’s still illegal to be gay, agrees. “If you go section 377 in Singaporean law, it cites two men engaging in sexual activity as wrong and you can be jailed for that. There’s a huge push from the LGBT movement to get rid of that, but the government refuses to. Homophobia is still very prevalent in Singapore.”

She believes that in some areas of the world it does not make sense for gay engineers to be out, as in some regions homosexuality is punishable by death. “In the Middle East you can be killed for being gay, it’s a very dangerous place to be out.”

Gender diversity

Tim Macavoy, events director at professional technology and engineering diversity network InterTech and UX editor at Skype, says that for lesbian and transgender engineers, being discriminated against because of their sexuality is only the tip of the iceberg. “Certain areas of the engineering industry lends itself to homogeneous cultures, and that can be difficult to work in. Engineering in general struggles with attracting gender diversity, as well as LGBT, and I think this is something the industry as a whole is very aware of.”

Worryingly, some of our 34 lesbian respondents still experience gender discrimination at work, with one participant saying: “I don’t necessarily feel there is any explicit discrimination in terms of being lesbian. I think there are far more issues/discrimination purely related to being a woman.”

Of the 17 transgender participants in our survey, many felt it was “not appropriate to be out”, regarding their transsexuality.  Many have experienced discrimination at work, with one citing archaic mindsets of senior management as the reason for hiding their transsexuality: “If I come out at work, what will that do to my prospects? I hear the sexist remarks from senior management. How much more will that affect a transgendered person who they have seen as male but wants to identify as female?”

Some have even had to leave the engineering profession altogether due to negative reactions at work: “People struggling with me being transgender have made it impossible for me to return to my previous occupation since I came out,” comments one respondent.

Direct discrimination

Only 7.7 per cent of respondents felt they’d been discriminated against work, and  were subjected to “slurs”, “mocking” and “homophobia”, with some questioning whether they’d picked the right career. One, who works in defence, says: “I had bad experiences when in the army, there’s not a chance in hell I’d ever tell anyone again.”

Despite respondents’ fears that their sexuality could hinder their career progression, 76.6 per cent have not experienced direct homophobic or gender discrimination from their peers. “I’ve not experienced any homophobic comments made to me about my sexual orientation,” says one. “I’ve experienced no hint of being treated differently to anyone else.”

Macavoy says this response is encouraging. “I think we’re becoming more aware that creativity comes from diversity and wild ideas and different backgrounds and experiences,” he says. “Some companies who are headed up only by straight, white men take a look around and say, ‘this probably isn’t good enough’. They want to change the way their organisations are run: they want to change their conversation with people.”

Methodology

A total of 356 engineers took part in our LGBT diversity survey in June 2014. They were asked to answer a series of questions relating to their openness about their sexuality in the workplace, whether they felt their sexuality was a barrier to career development, discrimination they’d experienced in the workplace and the sector and region in which they worked. Out of the 50 respondents who answered ‘other’ to our question regarding sexuality, 20 answered heterosexual. Unfortunately this fraction skewed our results by a minimal amount, which is normal during an open, online survey.

Further information

The IET's LGBT network

Share |
Related forum discussions
  Topic Replies  
forum comment Heterosexual does not skew the results 0 Reply

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1607

"As the dust settles after the referendum result, we consider what happens next. We also look forward to an international summer of sport."

E&T jobs

  • Chair in Integrated Sensor Technology

    The University of Edinburgh
    • Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh

    The University of Edinburgh is one of the world’s top 20 institutions of higher education.....

    • Recruiter: The University of Edinburgh

    Apply for this job

  • Principal Electrical Engineer - Power

    BAE Systems
    • Bristol, England / Cumbria, Barrow-In-Furness, England
    • Negotiable

    Principal Electrical Engineer - Power Join our Electrical Power team and help design the self-contained generation and distribution system for the Successor submarine - a new generation of submarine designed to carry the UK's independent nuclear deterrent

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Operations Supervisor (Mechanical/Electrical/Instrumentation)

    National Grid
    • England, Cambridgeshire
    • £33000 - £39000 per annum

    Operations Supervisor - (Mechanical/Electrical/Instrumentation) Salary: Circa £33k - 39k dependant on experience + vehicle and great additional benefits (share scheme, pension, potential bonus).Location: Wisbech - Cambridgeshire We currently have an excit

    • Recruiter: National Grid

    Apply for this job

  • Lead NDT Trainer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Lancashire
    • Competitive package

    Would you like to be involved with training UK and international teams in Non Destructive Inspection (NDI) to support the in service fleet (Typhoon Tornado, and Hawk)?

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Systems Design - Emerging Portfolio

    MBDA
    • Bristol
    • Competitive Salary & Benefits

    What?s the opportunity?   There are fantastic opportunities in Systems Design for engineers to work within Future Systems. These are highly visible, fast paced roles, in...

    • Recruiter: MBDA

    Apply for this job

  • Metering Engineer

    Department for Business, Innovation and Skills
    • Teddington, United Kingdom
    • £24,109 - £27,961 plus EO Electronics PE of £8,090.00

    We are now looking for a Metering Engineer to deliver RD’s In-Service Testing (IST) scheme for gas and electricity meters.

    • Recruiter: Department for Business, Innovation and Skills

    Apply for this job

  • Head of Operational Estates

    Premium job

    The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust
    • Shrewsbury, Shropshire
    • £46,625 to £57,640 per annum

    As an experienced Estates Manager, you will play a key role in helping to shape the future of the Estates service.

    • Recruiter: The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital NHS Trust

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Project Manager - Electrical & Automation

    Nestle
    • York, North Yorkshire
    • c£45,000 + Car Allowance + Bonus + Excellent Benefits

    Nestlé Product Technology Centre in York currently has an excellent opportunity for an Engineering Project Manager

    • Recruiter: Nestle

    Apply for this job

  • Assistant Professor (Tenure Track) of Smart Building Solutions

    Premium job

    ETH Zurich
    • Zurich, Canton of Zürich (CH)

    The successful candidate is expected to develop a strong and visible research programme in the area of control and diagnostics of building systems

    • Recruiter: ETH Zurich

    Apply for this job

  • Process Controls Leader

    Premium job

    Phillips 66
    • Humber Refinery, South Killingholme, North Lincolnshire DN40 3DW
    • £60k - 75k plus extensive Compensation and benefits package, dependent upon experience

    Experienced Process Control Leader providing leadership and technical support for Oil Refinery. Extensive Compensation and benefits package.

    • Recruiter: Phillips 66

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶

Subscribe

Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T