R&D at the BBC: can the Beeb sustain its tech reputation?
We have the BBC to thank for many tech advances from the last two centuries, but can the world-famous public service sustain its R&D activities?
The BBC is responsible for a myriad of innovations ranging from FM stereo radio and teletext to interactive television services that are accessible via the red button.
The British Broadcasting Corporation has been a front runner of communications development since its creation in the early 1920s. The captains of the radio industry, led by Marconi, Radio Communication Company, Metropolitan-Vickers, General Electric, Western Electric and British Thomson-Houston, met at the London-based headquarters of the Institution of Electrical Engineers (IEE) to discuss how to market radio sets to the general public.
"It's the old chestnut that is still problematic for consumer electronic companies today: 'We've created the technology, now we have to ensure that the content is available'," says Paul Gray, European director of research firm Displaysearch.
The answer was simple, under the auspices of these companies – and with a little help from The IEE – the BBC was created as an experiment in November 1922 and it was to be funded in a 'unique' way. Unlike American commercial radio stations, which ran paid-for advertising, the new service was to be financed by a license fee payable annually by radio set owners.
The BBC has since been at the vanguard of broadcast and consumer technologies in television, radio and the Internet. In fact, research and development is enshrined in the BBC's Royal Charter between the BBC and the government.
The charter states: "The Executive Board must ensure that the BBC conducts research and development activities geared to the promotion of the BBC's Public Purposes and which aim to maintain the BBC's position as a centre of excellence for research and development in broadcasting and other means for the electronic distribution of audio, visual and audiovisual material, and in related technologies."
Yet the BBC is probably facing its biggest battle for its existence since the coalition government came into power four years ago. In 2010, the then newly formed government capped the licence fee at £145.50 for six years – in real terms a 16 per cent cut by 2016.
Additionally, the BBC has signed up to fund extra commitments including the World Service. This deal also means that it is funding the rollout of superfast broadband to rural areas to the tune of £150m.
In total, the BBC will be spending an extra £340m of licence-fee money before the end of next year.
Although some of the cuts are to come from rolling back the content the BBC provides – such as the planned axing of the BBC Three digital television service, others will inevitably fall on the R&D projects.
Director general of the BBC, Tony Hall, announced last year that a flagship IT project by the BBC, the Digital Media Initiative (DMI), would be abandoned after five years and spending of approximately £98m. This led to an apology to the Parliamentary Public Accounts Select Committee in May 2013 by the current management and a subsequent apology by Mark Thompson, the former director general.
John Linwood, BBC chief technology officer at the time of DMI's demise, was sacked and is now pursuing a legal case against the company for wrongful dismissal.
The DMI project was to provide the BBC with digital asset management, video ingest and software-based encoding, broadcast automation and playout, production tools, and archive storage and retrieval – all integrated into one seamless database-driven production workflow. It would also incorporate an online storyboarding system as well as metadata storage and sharing.
The overarching plan was to make archived content available on the desktop of all BBC staff anywhere in the world. This would have allowed them to develop, create, share and manage video and audio as well as access content.
The project was initiated by the director of BBC Technology at the time, Ashley Highfield, with £81m of funding outsourced to Siemens in 2008. Siemens' contract, however, was terminated in a £27.5m settlement only a year later.
Despite being subsequently rejected by the BBC finance committee and criticised by the National Audit Office, the project was'partly outsourced to a consortium of three IT companies – Computacenter, Mediasmiths & Vidispine – in 2011. Two years later, the BBC's newly anointed director general threw in the towel and canned the whole project.
The BBC says it will now use off-the-shelf technology to support its production processes, but it is not ready to provide details of its plans. The broadcaster could face a bill of many more millions of pounds for purchasing off-the-shelf technology, with some industry experts pointing to solutions such as Adobe Anywhere.
Outsourcing and collaboration
The BBC, like many media organisations are following the general trend to outsource a great deal of its technology development.
"The impact though, if it goes wrong, can be publicly visible with an immediacy and scale unlike that of any other business," says Mike Cronk, partner at Marquis Media Partners, a firm that specialises in advising broadcast organisations on technology development.
The BBC has outsourced much of its technology infrastructure in the last few decades. Responsibility for its transmitter assets used to lie solely within the Corporation until 1997 when the assets were then split into a separate company, prior to being sold. The terrestrial signal that the BBC now relies on is run by Arqiva, which also inherited many of the engineers that developed DAB (digital audio broadcast) radio and the original digital video broadcasting (DVB) standard, which eventually became Freeview.
Collaboration with other broadcasters is also an important factor in how the BBC's R&D operations work. Super Hi-Vision, for example, a large-screen television system, is primarily being developed by Japanese national broadcaster NHK in their Science and Technical Research Laboratories.
It has a picture resolution 16 times greater than HD and includes 22.2-channel surround sound, including some speakers at ceiling height to provide a 3D audio experience.
The BBC has been collaborating with NHK under the Broadcast Technology Futures (BTF) group – an association of NHK, The European Broadcast Union, the broadcasters RAI and IRT, and the BBC, with the aim to carry out research on a wide range of technologies.
Another example of such a collaboration is DAB radio, which was developed as a research project for the European Union and started in 1987 on initiative by a consortium formed in 1986. The first public demonstrations were made in 1993 by the BBC after the protocol specification was finalised. This was adopted by the ITU-R standardisation body in 1994, the European community in 1995 and by ETSI in 1997. Pilot broadcasts were launched in several countries in 1995.
Thus, the UK was the first country to receive a wide range of radio stations via DAB. Commercial DAB receivers began to be sold in 1999 and over 50 commercial and BBC services were available in London by 2001.
It is now an international standard which is coordinated by the World DMB Forum since 1997 (formerly the World DAB Forum), which represents more than 30 countries.
Another UK-specific example would be Project Canvas, a video-on-demand platform which is a collaboration between the BBC, BT, ITV, Channel 4, Channel Five and TalkTalk. It is fairly unique in that it is a collaboration between competitors, and it now exists as the television and set-top box platform Youview.
Is it the BBC's corporate structure and culture which makes it more difficult to encourage the left-field thinking that often leads to tangible innovation?
In the 1990s, for example, the director general John Birt introduced an internal market at the company called Producer Choice, which also extended to the supply of research effort. The R&D department became an in-house supplier of research facilities, with the projects purchased by separate units within the BBC.
There will always be problems in applying market forces to research and development functions within an organisation such as the BBC. This often results from a unified department attempting to deal with multiple customers, each with different priorities. The BBC's internal market was slowly dismantled by Birt's successors until it was non-existent by 2006.
Today, the BBC works and shares best practice with many in-house R&D labs with other state and commercial broadcasters. This is in tune with the BBC's current charter, which makes it clear that it is the organisation's responsibility to maintain open standards.
"Even though it may not take a lead in the creation of many of these future technologies, such as 4K and 16K standards, the only way for [the BBC] to influence them is to gain a deep understanding through contributing to the technologies even if it may seem token," says Displaysearch's Gray.
The R&D department's future depends on working closely with its R&D counterparts in other broadcasting associations. It's no longer the vehicle of a British consumer technology industry, which has since moved on to Japan and Korea whose broadcasters have the stronger motivation to develop and promote future broadcasting innovations.
The BBC was invited to comment on this article, although it did not respond in time for the print version of this article, which appears in volume 9, issue 6, of E&T magazine.
However, a BBC spokesperson has since us sent the following information:
"Research and development plays a crucial role in enabling the BBC to create and deliver innovative high-quality content and services, as cost-effectively as possible to the licence fee paying public. The BBC’s R&D team has consistently pioneered exciting new technologies for its audiences - from the birth of radio and TV, to the first steps into the digital world with BBC Micro Computers and Ceefax, through to Freeview, digital switchover, BBC iPlayer and the technology to deliver the first truly digital Olympics in 2012.
"BBC R&D continues this tradition with a multitude of leading-edge projects that are shaping the future of television and how audiences access and enjoy new forms of content. For example, only recently we announced a broadcasting first where live Ultra-High Definition coverage from the World Cup will be distributed simultaneously over traditional broadcast and internet technologies in a trial. We are working with partners to deliver this and have always followed a philosophy of collaboration and openness, working regularly with other broadcasters, standard’s bodies and technology partners."
BBC R&D achievements
BBC forms research department to develop short-wave radio and studio and broadcast equipment
Telerecording equipment is developed for the Queen's Coronation, which is broadcast live and recorded for future posterity
First stereo FM broadcasts in the UK
The first test transmission of Ceefax on the BBC which became the international teletext
The BBC broadcasts programmes using their NICAM stereo service in the UK, the first stereo TV service in the world, which quickly becomes an international standard
The Eureka radio standard is adopted in the UK as DAB Radio – all local and national BBC radio stations adopt the new standard
BBC Red button interactive services replace Ceefax
"Our summer watersports special: surfing artificial waves, racing yachts for sport, superyachts for pleasure and much more besides"
- Japan sweetens high-speed rail offer to Indonesia
- Self-healing polymer could protect future spacecraft against meteorites
- Automakers sued over 'dangerous' keyless ignitions
- Smart 3D printed micro-fish could improve detoxification
- Key component of Hubble successor arrives for assembly
- Girls as young as seven put off engineering