vol 9, issue 2

Mission-critical location-based services

14 February 2014
By Bryan Betts
Share |
Hand held GPS

Smartphones enabled with LBS-based applications should help users to navigate interiors

Simon Reed

Simon Reed, TfL: “The ability to know a service is coming is an incentive to operators to run according to contract.”

Buses on Oxford Street

The introduction of visual and audible next-stop announcements was a big location-based technology win for TFL

A man using a mobile phone in a city

The architectural concrete canyons found in dense urban environments can cause problems with locating GPS satellites

Fire fighters

Four firefighters died in 2007 because they ran out of oxygen before they could find their way out of a burning building

Location-based services on mobile devices used to be the preserve of app-happy shoppers and geo-social networking. Now, their usefulness is being explored for more serious – even mission critical – situations.

On the mobile phone as a 'platform', location is everywhere. It may not be king, but pretty much any app that aims to provide a service now includes a location-based element, whether it is to help you find a nearby restaurant or minicab, or simply to push local promotions your way. The space-satellite-based Global Positioning System (GPS) is the key enabler. Even low-end smartphones now include not just a GPS chip, but can also locate themselves by scanning for local mobile basestations and Wi-Fi access points.

In serious business though, location's use has been limited. It is big in logistics; virtually all buses and most commercial vehicles (such as vans and lorries) will now have GPS locators fitted to help with service-tracking and route optimisation. But there is a whole group of applications where location information could make a huge difference to the good, but where GPS is in practice either too inaccurate, too slow, or simply not available.

This was illustrated in 2007, when four Warwickshire firefighters died in a large smoke- and flame-filled vegetable packing factory. This tragedy occurred not because the burning building collapsed, but because the firefighters ran out of oxygen before they could find their way out of the stricken premises. It is unlikely that a satnav or smartphone would have helped save them – they were inside a steel-framed and clad building where 3G signals would have been weak, and GPS contact non-existent.

Even when smartphone users are outdoors, and when lives are not immediately at risk, GPS can prove inadequate. For example, the architectural concrete canyons found in dense urban environments can cause problems, with the receiver unable to 'see' enough of the sky to lock on to enough GPS satellites. In built-up areas where a lock-on is possible, the situation is better now since the US turned off the deliberate fuzzying of civilian GPS in 2000, but your position fix can still be tens of metres out.

Two overlapping areas of research are now coming to the rescue. The first is alternative location technologies, ranging from counting how many steps you have taken to measuring subtle shifts in the geomagnetic field. The second is the use of sophisticated algorithms to merge location data from multiple sources, thereby using different location technologies to correct each other's errors.

Schemes like these are now widely used. For example, a car satnav system will constrain its options by assuming that you are on the closest road and following your programmed route, not in the middle of the field next to it. A smartphone will take data from the network to help lock onto satellites (assisted GPS, which can in many cases much improve the start-up performance, or time-to-first-fix (TTFF), of a GPS-based positioning system), and can also try to locate itself according to which cell basestations and Wi-Fi access points it can see. The nature of radio waves still means, however, that this may not be accurate enough to avoid accidentally shooting your own comrades on the battlefield, to navigate through a darkened building, or to report the location of an emergency by mobile phone.

"With fixed-line phones we can get the location from BT, but it is more challenging with IP phones and mobiles," explained Olaf Baars, chief fire officer at Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue Service, speaking at the October 2013 Cambridge Wireless event 'Locations and Beyond 2013: Knowing where you will be tomorrow (means so much more)', which was sponsored by CSR, and produced in partnership with Silicon South West and the IET. "Even when mobile phones have GPS, there are GPS-denied environments – complex structures such as shopping malls and airports, or buildings with multiple basements. Structures often attenuate wireless too, for example due to the use of metal-backed boards in building."

Even when lives are not at stake, "we spend 80 per cent of our time inside buildings, so we will probably want to enable a lot of location-based services for indoor use", says Hamid Ahmadi, VP/chief innovation officer at wireless semiconductor specialist CSR (formerly Cambridge Silicon Radio), adding that there are several challenges here. For instance, access points are designed for communication, and not for location, so it is important to ask yourself how much dedicated positioning infrastructure you are willing to build, and whether you really need position or merely proximity. Ahmadi adds: "Sometimes, just knowing you're in the building, or on the second floor, is enough".

The other issue is maps. "Google and others spend a lot of money on maps outdoors, but indoors is different," he continues. Sometimes, drawings or maps exist in some form – Google has done some indoor mapping, for instance, "but how will you bring them into your infrastructure? Who pays for them? Crowdsourcing is possible, but it means parsing a lot of unstructured data – the problem with crowd-sourcing is you get more noise than data – and again there are privacy issues".

These are early days, but it seems obvious that where LBS data services exist to serve public interiors – shopping malls, say, or large visitor attractions – that that information should be available for other parties, such as emergency services, should the need arise; and that that requirement be built into the software's specification from the outset.

Consumer-grade location has all historically been based on GPS or cell signal strength, "and that can be rather inaccurate in urban settings", says Andy Thurman, the CEO of mesh network and location technology developer Omnisense. "If you give permission, Google then tracks you past every Wi-Fi access point and maps you from that, it's pretty good – but not quite as real-time as what we're doing. Performance is adequate for most consumer services though, where the bigger aim is to make it seamless to the user."

Life-saving LBS?

Other places where accurate location data could save lives include in mines and similar subterranean environments, and aboard ocean-going vessels. Thurman says: "At sea, it's tracking your crew in the engine room of a cruise ship, say, so you know everyone's evacuated before you pump in gas to kill a fire. In mining it's mainly for collision avoidance between vehicles and people. The signals can only propagate through the tunnels – they can't go through rock – but that means the bounce paths can't go miles off track. That's where you need multiple hops – a mesh network – in order to get the data out." The bounce paths are what Omnisense's wireless beacons use to communicate and locate each other, he notes.

A further option is opportunistic signals – spatially variable metrics that can be repurposed, says Dr Rob Harle, a researcher in the Computer Laboratory at University of Cambridge. As well as Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, light, heat, and the local magnetic field can all be highly repeatable. The challenge is that they require laborious surveying, plus they can change over time.

Dr Harle is therefore working on ways to combine opportunistic signals and the 'mobile phone's 'compass' with pedestrian dead-reckoning – basically, using the phone's accelerometer to count your steps. The problem is that dead reckoning accumulates errors over time, so he applies algorithms derived from robotics to correct these errors. In effect, each subsequent walk – around an office, a supermarket, or wherever – can recalibrate the basic Wi-Fi map.

Wheres and wherefores

In Transport for London's bus-tracking scheme, lateral thinking led to another opportunistic signal: bus drivers are only supposed to open the doors at a bus stop, and the Transport for London control system knows where its 19,000 bus stops are, so it can use the doors opening to narrow down a bus's location.

"The system transmits the vehicle location'to base every 30 seconds, it also transmits every time the doors open," says Simon Reed, head of Transport for London's Technical Services Group. "There is a thing now about how much more information we can get off. For example, the weight of the bus is a proxy for the number of people onboard, we also get the number of Oyster cards scanned."

Oyster is Transport for London's contactless smartcard ticketing system, introduced in July 2003. More than 43 million Oyster Cards have been issued. It'now accounts for more than 80 per cent of all public transport journeys that take place in the capital.

Of course, what you do with the location data is just as important as how you gather it. "A consumer device may know where you are – that's useful for pushing services to you – but in our applications it's more situational awareness and command and control, so there is a central repository," explains Omnisense's Thurman.

"I cannot stress enough that without an accurate data supply, we would be finished," agrees Reed. "The ability to accurately know a service is coming is very important, it's also an incentive to the operators to run according to their contract – the operators get the same information we have, they can see their vehicles and talk directly to the drivers, for example to speed up or slow down the vehicle to maintain service frequency."

The introduction of visual and audible next-stop announcements across its bus fleet in 2009 was a big location-based technology win for Transport for London. "Making that ubiquitous has helped greatly," says Reed.

"A lot of the stuff we do is for service control," he adds, "but we also use the same data to performance-manage the network and inform passengers – as well as the countdown signs on bus stops, it's essential for the audio location signal which has made the bus network so much easier to use."

Reed adds that Transport for London also publishes more than 50 data sources, typically by transport medium, all of them free for anyone to use and analyse. "The last time we looked, there were 60 apps using our bus data alone, and over 190 apps doing things for passengers," he reveals. "Some apps merge our data sources to improve your travel experience and planning – we would not merge sources and do syntheses ourselves due to budget constraints."

And all of this is based on the slimmest of data feeds. "When the system was put together in 2006 data was expensive, so the vehicle only transmits 52 bytes every 30 seconds, although we also collect more data as it passes certain Wi-Fi points around London," Reed explains.

"Technology has to have a business use. Sure, we could livestream video from the bus, say... but that's not useful. However, 52 bytes every 30 seconds – now that is useful. Then it's what you can do with the data and give back to people, and what they can do with it after that."

Further information

Share |

Emergency response: vital role of Positioning in situation safety

Location is a huge challenge for the emergency services even before an incident happens, says Olaf Baars, chief fire officer at the Royal Berkshire Fire and Rescue Service. "You need to plan for the right resources in the right place, and that means understanding the risk profile and the statistical profile of risk," he explains. "Geo-demographic data can tell you with phenomenal accuracy where fires will occur, but [not] when fires will occur.

"Ambulances aim for an eight-minute response, with fire and police it's 8-10'minutes for the first response, then a second appliance in 10-12 minutes."

For the fire service, once an incident is under way the need switches from localisation or proximity to highly accurate positioning that works not just in a smoke-filled building or a burning forest, but through steam too. That's because, as Baars notes, "much of the water you put on a fire comes rushing back at you at 1,700 times its volume, in the form of superhot steam".

There is an EU-backed international project called Smart@Fire underway, with the aim of specifying smart personal protective systems for firefighters, possibly'including smart clothing - and definitely including location-based technology. A key part of this project involved assessing the various location mechanisms available, and their strengths and weaknesses both indoors and outdoors. For instance, the 2.4GHz band used by Bluetooth and most Wi-Fi networks can be heavily affected by fire and water, although Baars says it is more often the physical structure and properties of the building that is the problem - and in any case, one of the first things firefighters will do in an emergency is cut the electrical supply.

"We need greater in-building penetration," he adds. "The 450-470MHz spectrum range allocated to the emergency services is under-used and offers some opportunities. Also, location-based information is part of an overall need for emergency services to share data better." He notes that while it might be possible to piggyback location onto the fire alarm system or have location technology built into buildings, not all buildings will have that so the real need is for an independent location service.

"For example, [in an emergency situation] you might have a head-up display showing your and your colleagues' positions on a map, with a path to retrace your steps," he says. "The technology must be lightweight - it's important that it doesn't create any additional physiological burden, it must not be reliant on building infrastructure, and it must be reliable and accurate. It should provide your location to the incident commanders too."

When Transport for London, the body which oversees public transport in the capital, needed a system back in 2006 to track its many thousands of red buses, it discovered that obvious methods such as GPS or triangulating on the closest mobile base stations were not accurate enough for its needs (more about this deployment elsewhere in this feature).

"GPS is not enough in central London," explains Simon Reed, head of transport for London's Technical Services Group. "If you were doing this system now, yes you would look at using multiple SIMs and cell location, but in 2006, cell location wasn't an option - some of our route is rural and the coverage isn't there, it's poor in some central areas too, despite what the network operators tell you."

The solution developed by Transport for London, and its technical partner Siemens, was to layer on other positioning methods and then add constraints where possible. "It's very hard to get right," says Reed. "We take an odometer feed and we define service corridors, the vehicle also has a compass. GPS is then an enhancement."

Technology trends: Phones on the hook in the 'Internet of things'

As a technology evolves, commodity implementations usually win out over bespoke ones. Basically, once the former can do 80 per cent of the latter's job for 20 per cent of its cost, users find ways to cope without that little extra capability. This is already starting to happen in the case of smartphones, even though GPS and triangulation have their problems, suggests CSR's chief innovation officer Hamid Ahmadi.

"A lot of smart devices these days have [other] sensors you can use - accelerometers, a digital compass," even the microphone and camera, he says. In a sense, LBS-enabled smartphones become part of the so-called Internet of Things; and when the location-based data that they transmit starts to be used by'other resources as a matter of course, they will also become integral to the growing web of machine-to-machine networks.

"There are techniques such as image recognition, ultrasonics, and infrared lights. Applications could include access control and people-counting, while smart IT and bring-your-own-device could for example grant different access rights depending on where you are in a building."

A small number of the bespoke applications will still need the sort of fast and highly accurate location that smartphones cannot provide, argues Omnisense CEO Andy Thurman, but he says that even these are benefiting from the commodity effect.

So while Omnisense's proprietary technology requires timing signals that it can't yet implement on smartphones, "the advance of consumer devices and the consequent reduction in the cost of sensors such as accelerometers and gyros has enabled us to also take those. For example we can use inertial sensors developed for smartphones, and they're $1 or $2 each. They're less accurate [than high-end sensors] but we can correct for that in software, so we are using consumer componentry in a bespoke design".

Related forum discussions
forum comment To start a discussion topic about this article, please log in or register.    

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1607

"As the dust settles after the referendum result, we consider what happens next. We also look forward to an international summer of sport."

E&T jobs

  • Protection and Control Engineer

    • Glasgow, Perth, Inverness or Aberdeen
    • £36,000 - £54,000 Plus Car and Bonus

    To ensure that the network continues to run effectively, we are looking to recruit a Protection and Control Engineer to join our existing teams....

    • Recruiter: SSE

    Apply for this job

  • Control Systems Engineer

    United Utilities
    • Lancaster, Lancashire
    • Up to £33415 + Comprehensive Benefits

    Provide ICA maintenance and engineering support to the Water & Wastewater Production

    • Recruiter: United Utilities

    Apply for this job

  • Principal Systems Engineer

    BAE Systems
    • England, Surrey, Frimley / Dorset, England, Weymouth
    • Competitive package

    Would you like to be involved in designing, developing, and delivering cutting edge combat systems for the world's most advanced military submarines? BAE Systems is recruiting Principal Systems Engineers

    • Recruiter: BAE Systems

    Apply for this job

  • Gas Terminal Engineer

    National Grid
    • Aberdeenshire, Scotland
    • £41000 - £49000 per year

    Gas Terminal Engineer (Oil/Gas/Petrochemical)- St. Fergus, Scotland - National GridSalary: £41-49k depending on experience, plus excellent benefits including: Performance Bonus, a generous pension scheme, flexible benefits, company car We currently have a

    • Recruiter: National Grid

    Apply for this job

  • Associate Network Opportunities

    Premium job

    Smarter Grid Solutions
    • Flexible but may need to spend time in Glasgow, London or New York offices

    We are always keen to work with relevant industry professionals on an associate basis.

    • Recruiter: Smarter Grid Solutions

    Apply for this job

  • Electronics & Control Systems Engineer

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Glasgow, Plymouth, Warrington
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    We are seeking talented Electronics Engineers at all career levels.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Control and Instrumentation Engineers

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Glasgow, Gloucester
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    Frazer-Nash is currently embarking on a period of significant growth of our electrical, electronics, control and instrumentation capability.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Officer

    Royal Air Force
    • Nationwide
    • £30k pay after initial training + £10k Golden Hello

    Responsible for the optimum performance of all RAF technology, and specialise in either Aerosystems or Communications Electronics.

    • Recruiter: Royal Air Force

    Apply for this job

  • Junior Automation Engineer

    • Worthing, West Sussex

    Your job will directly contribute to the lives of patients receiving our products

    • Recruiter: GSK

    Apply for this job

  • E & I Craftspersons

    • South East England

    An opportunity has arisen to recruit a number of experienced Electrical and Instrumentation Craftsperson’s....

    • Recruiter: SGN

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶


Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T