vol 8, issue 3

'Data hunger' will cause 4G roll-out to feel the bite

11 March 2013
By Chris Edwards
Share |
Graphic showing hungry smartphones eating fish shaped data

Data hungry smartphones will need more than 4G to slake their consumption appetites

Friends chatting on the phone back to back

Talkative 4G subscribers may not know that their voice traffic is offloaded onto 3G networks

A coffee table with an Ubiquisys unit and a Kindle on it

Compact femtocells, such as this from Ubiquisys, will increasing form part of the connectivity fabric

A communications basestation

‘Macrocell’ basestations will remain important to the roll-out of 4G services

Smartphones designed to exploit the emerging 4G networks are ravenous for data, and that's good news for service operators who need ways to maximise usage-based revenue models. But the transition from 3G to 4G is likely to throw up several contentious issues that will take time and effort to reconcile.

When work started on Long-Term Evolution (LTE), the cellular technology designed to replace 3G, the plan was to provide data rates that could keep pace with handset technology. Now demand threatens to outstrip supply, and 4G is mutating into a new kind of wireless network.

It will be a network which, instead of relying mostly on large 'macrocell' basestations, will give way to an extended fabric of much smaller 'femtocell' transceivers sitting in people's homes or 'metrocells' that hang off street lamp posts.

For the wireless industry, "this transition is what the PC was for the computer industry", says Rupert Baines, vice president of strategic marketing at semiconductor firm Mindspeed. "It's the same philosophy of small, cheap things pushed out to the edge, rather than the focus on big iron tended by teams of experts that we saw with mainframes."

Driving the transition is the ravenous hunger for data that the smartphone has brought with it. A study by wireless-networks usage specialist Arieso of wireless usage on a major European operator's network found that each new generation of smartphone is much more hungry for data than the last.

"There is a device war going on; each new device constitutes a new front line," says Michael Flanagan, CTO at mobile solutions provider Arieso. "There has been a 50 per cent increase in usage with each generation."

As an example, iPhone 5 users typically transfer four times more data than people with the original iPhone 3. The reason for the explosion in smartphone data usage seems to be down to their always-on nature, Flanagan reckons. People keep their phones active to be able to take calls - "And data will continue'in the background," Flanagan explains. When not being actively prodded and stroked by users, tablets are far less likely to have persistent data connections and are used more often in Wi-Fi zones, so feature less in cellular data-usage measurements.

"We are moving towards 1GB per day per consumer by 2020," notes Kai Sahala, head of mobile broadband marketing at cellular equipment vendor Nokia Siemens Networks. "We see that being consumed by some users already with some LTE subscriptions."

Simply shifting from 3G to 4G technology can handle some of the necessary increase in capacity but with all its data-coding techniques LTE is now close to the Shannon limit - the maximum theoretical data rate that can be achieved for a given slice of radio spectrum.

"There are only a few ways to get more capacity out of your spectrum," says Nick Johnson, CTO of picocell/femtocell vendor Ip.access. One option is to use the higher frequencies that are less congested, "but the propagation of radio above a few gigahertz becomes very difficult. You can't get more than a few tens of metres", Johnson adds. "The other option is to split the cells into smaller chunks. Cells have to get smaller to reuse the same spectrum over and over again."

Adding cells sounds easy but is far from trivial. "Most tier-one operators are running out of places to put traditional macrocell basestations," says Arieso's Flanagan. One answer is to scale down, using much smaller femtocells and metrocells. This is where the heterogeneous network or 'het-net' comes in. "The idea is to manage small cells within a macrocell network," says Johnson.

Sahala says operators can optimise how they split radio frequencies across the basestations in a het-net. Lower frequencies can propagate more easily - those released by the switching off of analogue TV are much better than those above 1GHz that were allocated for 3G, and which EE is using for its initial LTE network in the UK.

Those higher frequencies are likely to end up being allocated to small cells. The small cells do not need to be based purely on LTE. Pockets of Wi-Fi-based access are already up and running. They are used by operators to try to offload traffic from their 3G networks although at the present time, users have to manage the switch between Wi-Fi and cellular themselves.

"Then you find the Wi-Fi network congests while there is capacity on 3G," says Johnson, because people naturally assume that Wi-Fi will deliver better performance, which is fine until too many people are on that part of the network. In principle, the self-organising network (SON) software that controls the various basestations and Wi-Fi nodes can'look at where the network has capacity, and then switch users on to it. The first step is session-based control in which the SON allocates a user to Wi-Fi or cellular when they first appear and that is where they stay until they move out of range or stop using the service. Another user arriving just seconds later may be given a different allocation.

"When you want a more sophisticated approach, you want to be able to switch networks during a session. If LTE gets busy, you can move a user to Wi-Fi," says Johnson, "but you can optimise occupancy to within 5 per cent using just session-based control."

Flanagan argues that the importance of Wi-Fi is receding. "Offload means to me 'please offload me off Wi-Fi'." He argues that the proliferation of Wi-Fi access leads to interference issues that the more precisely planned cellular networks do not experience.

Baines says Wi-Fi still has a chance, especially with more recent versions of the standard. "When you've got 5GHz Wi-Fi the range isn't great but if you're sitting in a coffee shop that's fine, and the bandwidth is whopping. Most phones have built-in support for 802.11n that will handle higher data rates."

Wi-Fi offloading benefits

Ip-access's Nick Johnson says operators are moving back to seriously considering Wi-Fi for offload purposes: "The momentum is coming. Operators used to see it as a threat but now see the opportunity. They see a way to manage it, using technology from the cellular side." As the intelligence of the het-net evolves, it will make more strategic decisions. As the user moves around they could quickly move in and out of range of many small cells.

Although cellular standards have robust handover protocols, each handover increases the risk of a dropped connection. The SON can be used to detect users moving at faster than walking pace - which indicates they are in a vehicle that could quickly move out of range - and avoid connecting them to small-cell basestations even if they would get better data rates for brief periods. "The software may switch you to a macrocell if you get on a bus," says Mindspeed's Baines.

Because they will usually lie within the confines of another basestation that is operating on a different set of frequencies to avoid mutual interference, macrocell and metrocell basestations can be used in more complex ways. The two types of basestation have very different levels of output power.

You can hang a metrocell off a lamp post because its radio transmissions are much weaker and so have a much smaller coverage area than those from a macrocell transmitter that has to sit at the top of a tall tower.

Devices will often be in a zone just beyond the edge of the metrocell or femtocell's nominal range, which should put it into the zone of the macrocell; but, Anders Furusk'r, technologist at Ericsson Research, points out that the phone has to transmit data to the basestation as well and has to use more power to reach a macrocell that may be further away than the femtocell.

The best answer is to make the device receive data from one and send data to the other; that takes a lot of coordination in the 'backhaul' network that links the two basestations together. ABI Research's principal analyst Aditya Kaul maintains that Ericsson is pushing for these advanced features. There is a catch: they only work well where the equipment vendor has tight control over the software and hardware used right across the het-net.

Although metrocells will be much cheaper to buy than macrocell basestations, there are still obstacles to overcome, such as wiring them up to the core network through backhaul links, and civic red-tape: convincing local authorities to host them on their publicly-owned street furniture.

"The question is how cost-effective it is for operators to deploy," says ABI Research's Aditya Kaul "That will determine what proportion of LTE will have small cells. The overall cost of small cells comes from not just the access point itself but the backhaul, management and site acquisition."

He adds: "All of that does add up to a lot of money. It will take time for some of that cost to reduce, especially the backhaul cost, site acquisition and management. Given the rate at which bandwidth needs are increasing, the rise of the small cell as part of the radio access network (RAN) seems inevitable. Operators will not be too fussy about which particular protocols they then use. Nick Johnson at Ip.access calls it the "Shannon-limit RAN": "Those technologies are all as close as makes no difference to their Shannon limits. The trick then is to make a network from multiple radio standards that all behave the same way: Wi-Fi, 3G, 4G integrated in one box with much of the intelligence moving to the edge."

Further information

Share |

Emerging technologies: how Packetisation brings benefits for voice and data

LTE is meant to be the first mobile network to behave the same way as the Internet. Designed for data, LTE is entirely packet-switched - a contrast to earlier phone standards which attempted to overlay data on a backbone that was circuit-switched, much like the traditional wired telephone network. Ever since the invention of the telephone, operators have treated voice traffic differently as needing a persistent connection and built standards around that assumption.

It was only with the upgrade to HSPA+ in the past couple of years that data traffic on 3G was handled more like a stream of packets. Before HSPA+, when your phone downloaded a Web page it would hold the connection open while you read the page, effectively blocking other users and reducing their overall datarate.

In contrast, LTE's IP Multimedia Subsystem (IMS) will treat even voice traffic as a series of independent packets in much the same way that services such as Skype route video and voice calls. Eventually.

Moving to packet-switched voice is not as simple as it seems. It takes time to roll out a wireless network and operators need to make money from the investment as they install the new equipment.

"They also have to bring support in on the device side. It's not just a switch you can turn on overnight," says ABI Research principal analyst Aditya Kaul.

The best focus for 4G is on its sweet spot of high-speed data, which is largely confined to areas where data-intensive users tend to congregate. For most operators, LTE is not carrying any voice traffic at all. Until early 2012 there was not even a standard way of getting a clean handover from an LTE to 3G cell or vice versa because of the different ways in which the respective protocols handle traffic. As it shifts from the packet domain of LTE, the 3G basestation that takes over has to, in effect, set up a connection for a call that is already in progress. On the way to 4G it has to close the connection without actually dropping the call.

There are other issues, Ip.access CTO Nick Johnson points out: "A huge amount of voice infrastructure is already out there and it's very closely integrated with the 2G/3G network. If you want to make an emergency call, there are a number of redirects through which the call goes. When you dial 999 or 112 from a handset, that number gets redirected to a particular call centre based on the cell you are in. The infrastructure to do that is very tightly bound up with the 2G/3G infrastructure. To do that with IMS is a step too far for many operators."

As 3G and LTE will run in parallel for years to come operators could simply treat the latter as a data-only service. But that is an option that winds up more expensive in the long-term than pushing new software out to a running network. Calls contain periods of silence that could be used for other traffic, helping to maintain performance. Combined with better speech compression and the improved spectral efficiency, pushing voice traffic to LTE makes sense. There are other benefits.

Stephan Litjens, head of LTE product management, Nokia Siemens Networks, points to South Korea as an example of the way in which voice-over-LTE (VoLTE) could be sold as a service upgrade to users. Rather than use the better efficiency to pack voice data into a smaller space, operators are choosing to offer better quality using the so-called high-definition (HD) codecs. "Voice quality over LTE is much higher. Do people notice it? The answer is yes. Already in Korea, VoLTE is a differentiator," says Litjens. "Call setup with VoLTE is also very fast. People like that."

The economic situation for operators has changed, says Kaul - an expensive network upgrade is no longer on the cards for many, at least in the near future: "Two years back, even 12 months ago, it looked as though everyone was going LTE for voice. But it looks like they have done a U-turn in the past year."

Ultimately, operators will favour the long-term benefits of a transition to IMS, having learned lessons from the introduction of the iPhone 3G. At that point, the data being downloaded was not the problem, it was the amount of protocol overhead the new generation of phones created. "The network operator's obsession is signalling capacity. The core network capacity you need for signalling is significant," says Ip.access's Nick Johnson. "With the original iPhone it was signalling traffic that was killing it. They had to slow down apps. The femtocell architecture really helps to offload the network."

Offloading voice as well as data to the new generation of small cells will relieve the core network of signalling congestion. "All the redirection mechanisms needed for voice have a cost in the core networks. If you say you can do this as close to the edge as you can, their eyes light up. There is definitely a role for voice in small cells," Johnson claims.

Related forum discussions
forum comment To start a discussion topic about this article, please log in or register.    

Latest Issue

E&T cover image 1607

"As the dust settles after the referendum result, we consider what happens next. We also look forward to an international summer of sport."

E&T jobs

  • Electrician

    The Bristol Port Company
    • City of Bristol
    • C. £31,729 per annum plus supplements, benefits and overtime

    You’re a good team worker with a strong technical capacity – so bring your talents to a new role with one of the area’s leading employers.

    • Recruiter: The Bristol Port Company

    Apply for this job

  • Supply Restoration Team Manager (HV/SAP)

    • Oxford, Oxfordshire
    • Salary: £37,588 to £49,645 + Car (SSE8) Depending on skills and experience

    SSE is looking to recruit a Supply Restoration Team Manager to join our existing team in Oxford.

    • Recruiter: SSE

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Technical Lead - Global Operations, Engineering & Laboratory

    Pfizer Ltd
    • Kent

    An exciting opportunity has arisen to join a dynamic team of professional engineers, supporting the development of novel drugs.

    • Recruiter: Pfizer Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Supply Restoration Team Manager (HV/SAP)

    • Oxfordshire
    • Salary: £37,588 to £49,645 + Car (SSE8) Depending on skills and experience

    SSE is looking to recruit a Supply Restoration Team Manager into our office in Oxford.

    • Recruiter: SSE

    Apply for this job

  • Electronics & Control Systems Engineer

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Glasgow, Plymouth, Warrington
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    We are seeking talented Electronics Engineers at all career levels.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Control and Instrumentation Engineers

    Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd
    • Bristol, Burton, Glasgow, Gloucester
    • £ Competitive + Benefits

    Frazer-Nash is currently embarking on a period of significant growth of our electrical, electronics, control and instrumentation capability.

    • Recruiter: Frazer-Nash Consultancy Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Engineer

    Gridpower Ltd
    • Newcastle Upon Tyne, Tyne and Wear

    Co-ordination of all project design deliverables and the leadership of a project team to deliver overall project[s] Right First Time

    • Recruiter: Gridpower Ltd

    Apply for this job

  • Electrical Technician

    National Grid
    • England, Lancashire
    • £29000 - £34000 per year

    Electrical Technician - Gas Transmission - Ref. 11206Salary: £29k - £34k, call-out and standby allowance plus job requirement vehicleLocation: Nether Kellet Compressor Station (LA6 1HD), Lancashire National Grid plc is the operator of the GB gas transmiss

    • Recruiter: National Grid

    Apply for this job

  • Engineering Officer

    Royal Air Force
    • Nationwide
    • £30k pay after initial training + £10k Golden Hello

    Responsible for the optimum performance of all RAF technology, and specialise in either Aerosystems or Communications Electronics.

    • Recruiter: Royal Air Force

    Apply for this job

  • Senior Systems Engineer

    Strainstall Marine
    • Cowes, Isle of Wight
    • Competitive + Benefits

    Oversee all aspects of electronic & systems engineering, manufacturing, test engineering and hardware support activities

    • Recruiter: Strainstall Marine

    Apply for this job

More jobs ▶


Choose the way you would like to access the latest news and developments in your field.

Subscribe to E&T