UK satellite industry: still flying 50 years on
How the UK has maintained a leadership position in the satellite industry for over 50 years
Ariel 1’s body was built by Nasa, but its seven scientific payloads came from UK universities
SSTL’s NovaSAR small radar satellite: funded by the government’s 2010 Space Innovation and Growth Strategy
STRaND 1: an orbital smartphone with serious outreach
Amid general UK plc doom and gloom, one technology sector resolutely maintains a 10 per cent growth rate, and its prospects are always looking up.
The UK space industry is booming. No sooner did Guildford-based Surrey Satellite Technology Ltd unveil its new 3,700m2 satellite clean-room facility, than the European Commission chose the company to assemble the next batch of eight Galileo satellite navigation payloads – adding to the 14 that it is already building.
The country's leading space firm Astrium UK lost that bid (still enjoying a win-win result, however, being the main SSTL shareholder), but it can console itself with a full order-book dominated by its minibus-sized Eurostar E3000 telecom satellites - costing upwards of '100m each - along with prime contractor status for numerous European Space Agency missions:'the magnetic-mapping Swarm mission, made largely in Hertfordshire, launches this July.
UK universities and research centres, meanwhile, are themselves active players in the space field - the first instrument finished for Nasa's James Webb Space Telescope (pictured above) has been the UK-led Mid Infrared Instrument. The space industry contributes around '7.5bn to the UK economy annually. The Coalition has taken note and is sticking to the Labour government's 2010 Space Innovation and Growth Strategy, with activities including seedcorn technology investment - such as funding SSTL's NovaSAR small radar satellite - and a 'Catapult Centre in Space Applications' to foster novel downstream applications - where growth (and most of the UK space industry's 70,000 jobs) are concentrated. This will be based at Harwell in Oxfordshire, home to an existing ESA site.
This entire industry, and all its rampant growth, can be traced back directly to an epoch-making event half a century ago. On 26 April 1962, the Ariel 1 satellite was launched into an elliptical Earth orbit by a US Thor-Delta rocket from Cape Canaveral in the US, an occasion marked this month by a two-day London Science Museum symposium.
Weighing 62kg, Ariel 1's spherical gold-hued aluminium and fibreglass body was built by Nasa but its seven scientific payloads came from UK universities - the first time that British hardware reached space to stay. Previous experiments briefly rose out of the atmosphere aboard suborbital Skylark rockets launched from the British test range in Woomera, South Australia, from 1957.
"Scientists and the military shared a common interest in the upper atmosphere," recalls Ariel 1 team member Ken Pounds. "Ballistic missiles were the big new weapon, and the military wanted to know more about the medium through which they would fly."
Some early Skylark experiments were crude - such as detonating hand grenades to estimate atmospheric pressure - but UK researchers gained experience in designing for space conditions; so when Nasa offered to fly other nations' science experiments British researchers were first in line. "The Americans were happy that the payload from the Brits was not just some second-rate bundle of instruments, but really cutting-edge experiments to study the upper atmosphere and solar radiation," Pounds says.
Professor Peter Willmore of the University of Birmingham's School of Physics and Astronomy and member of the International Astronomical Union, led the UK involvement. He says: "It all happened very quickly by modern standards - from agreement to launch in under two years - but this was something we very much wanted to do, and it was really a different world with much less bureaucracy."
A telex link was installed between University College London, coordinating the payloads, and Nasa Goddard in Maryland. Like most early satellites, Ariel 1 would be 'spin-stabilised' - spinning like a top to maintain orientation - with probes sampling the surrounding void.
With a total of 520 transistors aboard, Ariel-1 also probed the frontiers of early 1960s technology. Ariel 1's X-ray detector incorporated the first proportional counter in orbit, measuring particles' actual energy spectra compared to simple Geiger counters previously flown. A 100-minute-duration tape recorder stored measurements made worldwide - another first.
"Industry worked closely with us," says Ariel veteran Ken Pounds. "The then-British Aerospace Corporation in Bristol worked on electronics, along with Pye Ltd in Cambridge; 20th Century Electronics near Croydon developed our X-ray detectors, based on nuclear industry experience."
An excited Nasa upgraded Ariel-1's ride rocket from the trouble-prone Scout to the larger Thor-Delta. Birmingham's Peter Willmore flew to the US with the payloads as luggage (which unfortunately travelled on to Bermuda for a day). In the weeks that followed launch, Ariel 1 threw light on the Earth-Sun connection, linking solar flares with X-ray surges for the very first time - but nemesis lay waiting.
"All of a sudden the X-ray detector went berserk," Pounds explains. The US Air Force had, on 9 July, detonated a nuclear weapon, Starfish Prime, at 400km altitude. Its radiation saturated several Ariel 1 instruments and degraded its solar panels.'The satellite continued operations until November 1964, but was eventually crippled (re-entering in 1976). "Fortunately the deal struck with Nasa was for six Ariels in all," adds Willmore. "This was always envisaged as a long-term programme, and lasted until the end of the 1970s." From Ariel 3 in 1967, satellites themselves were built in the UK.
"Ariel worked like a calling card, showing prospective partners what the UK could do," says team member Len Culhane. UK space was on a course of international partnerships that lasts until this year, beginning with a leading role in early European satellites. On the industrial side Ariel was no less influential, argues Doug Millard, Science Museum space curator: "It was the dynamism of the space scientists that actually necessitated UK industry to start learning how to build spacecraft."
That early experience helped the UK to take a leadership role in European telecommunications satellites at a time when many believed Europe's space programme should remain purely scientific - one 1971 analysis by the European Conference of Postal and Telecommunication Administrations estimated telecom satellite revenues would not even pay for the ground infrastructure needed, much less actual satellites; but for once the government championed the right horse - with lasting consequences. "Probably about 40 per cent of the world's commercial telecom satellites are now made in the UK," notes David Parker, science director of the UK Space Agency.
Satellite bodies are made at Astrium Stevenage and payloads at Astrium Portsmouth, the two sites defining a 'space corridor' along which much of the rest of the UK space industry is aligned; the actual integration of these two satellite halves occurs over at Astrium's Toulouse site, however. It is also, perhaps, one reason why the UK's space activities remain obscure: our national achievements stay camouflaged, as it were, within international cooperation.
It is true that within space science the UK generally works within an ESA context. Ken Pounds, later founder of Leicester University's space department, argues that is not necessarily a bad thing: "If you have to compete to get your payload on an ESA mission, it has to be a really good experiment. Standards are set highest in international scientific programmes."
Similarly, on the industrial side Astrium UK thrives within European aerospace behemoth EADS Astrium. Bob Graham, the company's head of engineering, recalls Stevenage when it was still turning out Blue Streak missiles: "In terms of in-house engineering manufacturing, we have seen fantastic growth since that 1960s start. With the investment we've put in over the last couple of years, we have got a capacity here for six to eight spacecraft per year."
Have Ariel-style national space missions gone forever? The UK Space Agency (UKSA) - founded as part of the 2010 growth strategy - holds operational control over the UK's '230m civil space budget. "We have a budget we can do things with, unlike the previous British National Space Centre where other organisations controlled different bits of budget," explains UKSA's Parker.
"Something like 85-90 per cent of our budget goes to ESA, because that is where most space programmes are built collectively across Europe," explains David Williams, UKSA director-general. However, he explains that UKSA has started backing national missions too, making its money go further with smaller, cheaper satellites - the kind of microsatellites that SSTL has made its name with, as well as the 10x10x10cm CubeSat standard.
Devised in California, with a cottage industry springing up to supply structures and subsystems, CubeSats make space access feasible for small businesses, university departments or amateur groups. An obvious comparison, perhaps, is the way kit-built PCs began the so-called democratisation of computing in the late 1970s.
Satellites for all?
This analogy with the evolution of the PC goes only so far, however. CubeSats have absolute power and performance limitations, and once launch costs are factored in, a mission might still cost the price of small house. There will also be legislative and regulatory considerations to be resolved. Satellite industry veteran Pounds still sees a lot of potential: "Where projects like this are really useful is in doing hands-on work, introducing the challenges, and excitement of space to a new generation."
Might Ariel 1 have flown as a CubeSat today? More or less, concludes Culhane: "You would never put all those experiments together on a single platform these days... but considering electronics miniaturisation, Ariel 1's X-ray detector could probably now fit onto a CubeSat."
Small steps for square-kind: New nanosatellite and microsatellite designs
There's more computing power in a smartphone than the spacecraft that put men on the Moon: so why not put a smartphone in orbit? STRaND-1 launches later this year, a 30cm-long extended CubeSat based around a Google Android phone. "There's so much advanced technology crammed inside a modern smartphone," explains Shaun Kenyon of Surrey Satellite Technology Ltd, which has developed it in a joint mission with the University of Surrey's Surrey Space Centre. "We want to test if it could stand up to actual space conditions."
The phone will run dedicated apps for educational outreach, one exploring how sensitive the in-built mic is to recorded yells played back on screen - is it really true that in space, no-one can hear you scream?
The UK Space Agency also regards CubeSats as a promising means of flight-testing promising space technologies: UKube-1, under construction by ClydeSpace in Glasgow, should be the first of many. Similarly sized to STRaND-1, the satellite will carry a new imager design and GPS receivers as well as the FunCube relay from amateur group AMSAT-UK - anyone who purchases their customised dongle can turn their PC into a satellite ground station.
CubeSats also hold scientific promise: UK universities are contributing to the EU-funded QB50 initiative, which intends to use the gradual re-entry of 50 CubeSats to probe the thermosphere, the least studied atmospheric layer, while UCL's Mullard Space Science Laboratory plans a CubeSat as the UK contribution to an Anglo-Russian mission called TwinSat, with two satellites mapping ionospheric disturbances to predict earthquakes hours or days in advance. "The linkage is already established," reports Alan Smith of MSSL. "We're just not sure how it works - yet."
SSTL has established that microsatellites - the next class up from nanosatellite CubeSats, size-wise - can do serious business in space. SSTL is integrating the TechDemoSat mission, backed by the UK's Technology Strategy Board and South East England Development Agency as well as UKSA. Launching by early 2013, TDS is testing test novel UK technologies requiring more performance than a CubeSat can muster.
"We put out a call to UK academia and industry for payloads they'd want to fly," says Doug Liddle, SSTL's head of science. Passengers include a reflected GPS detector to measure sea surface conditions, compact radiation detectors and a deorbit sail to help dispose of redundant satellites.
Timeline: Staking a claim on the 'Clarke Belt'
In 1945 RAF officer and future science-fiction author Arthur C Clarke first published a paper that suggested placing relay satellites in geostationary orbit, 36,000km up. As a maritime power with foreign dependencies, the UK grasped the potential of satellite communications earlier than most nations. Accordingly, the government took a lead role in European satcom programmes, staking a claim on the so-called 'Clarke Belt' that exists to this day. Here are six orbital achievement highlights from the last 50 years...
10 July 1962
Following on Ariel 1 in April,came the launch of Telstar-1, the first active, direct relay telecommunication satellite. The UK Post Office is a partner, though its involvement limited to building Cornwall's Goonhilly ground station. The non-geostationary satellite provides trans-Atlantic links for 20 minutes per each 2.5 hour orbit but falls foul of radiation from Starfish Prime, detonated the day before Telstar launched.
23 November 1974
The Ministry of Defence's Skynet 2B is launched to provide a secure link with Far East territories - the first geostationary comsat built outside the US or USSR. While Skynet 1A (pictured) and B, launched in 1969, were US-built built, this second generation pair is assembled by Marconi Portsmouth (2A being lost at launch earlier in 1974). Skynet 2B beats the Franco-German Symphonie A civilian comsat into orbit by just under a month.
12 May 1978
The second Orbital Test Satellite (OTS-2) launched, ESA's first comsat in orbit, built by a consortium headed by Hawker Siddeley Dynamics (later British Aerospace). With the supposedly international Intelsat organisation an American club - 52 per cent of its early 1970s funding came from outside the US, but 92 per cent of its budget was spent there - Europe creates Eutelsat in 1977 to operate European comsats (privatised in 2001).
20 December 1981
Marecs-A (Maritime European Communication Satellite) launched, the first maritime communications satellite providing voice, data and telex links, built by a consortium headed by British Aerospace with Inmarsat established to operate it (today a privatised FTSE 250 company). Marec-A's name indicates its status as a maritime version of ESA's European Communication Satellite (ECS), another programme led by British Aerospace, the first ECS being launched in 1984.
30 October 1990
Launch of Inmarsat-2 F1, the first Eurostar E1000 telecom satellite, designed by British Aerospace and Matra Marconi Space (now merged in Astrium). Inmatsat-2 F1 remains operational to this day. More than 60 Eurostar satellites have since been ordered, the design evolving over the next two decades into the more-powerful E2000 then E3000 versions.
24 September 2011
Eutelsat's 4600 kg Atlantic Bird 7 (since renamed Eutelsat 7 West A), launched into an Atlantic geostationary slot, is the latest of four Eurostar-E3000 satellites flown this year. 2013 will see the launch of the MoD's fourth Skynet 5 satellite - the latest Eurostar-derived member of the Comsat family that started it all.
|To start a discussion topic about this article, please log in or register.|
"Who's getting the best engineering education? And what did your careers advisor suggest you do when you leave school?"
- What to Specialise in Electronics Engineering?? [03:02 am 03/04/14]
- Britain to have just one remaining coal pit by the end of 2015 [01:11 am 03/04/14]
- LV Generator Star point earthing - UK [08:35 pm 02/04/14]
- East West Rail - the Oxford to Bedford route [07:33 pm 02/04/14]
- Small nuclear power [06:06 pm 02/04/14]
The essential source of engineering products and suppliers.
Tune into our latest podcast